How lean should you be?

The relationship between athlete body composition and performance is a delicate balance between fuelling the body for performance whilst maintaining a sport specific body type.

This subject can be a controversial one to discuss, so we are going to attack this subject with a degree of nuance and understanding that we cannot hide from the fact that body composition and ‘weight’ is important in sport, however the mindless chasing of weight at all costs or without a proper understanding of the impact that being too lean can be a huge decriment to performance and one that we have seen time and time again.

Understanding the Influence of Body Composition on Performance.

The Role of Body Fat in Performance.

Body fat is a crucial component of an athlete's body composition. While excess body fat can hinder performance in some sports, a certain level is essential for overall health and sustained energy. Fat is more than just an energy store, it acts as a signal to the body that we might be in a state of nutritional stress that can have implications for health, performance and reproduction.

Importance: Body fat serves as an energy reserve, particularly during prolonged endurance activities. However, excessive body fat can impede speed, agility, and power-to-weight ratio, especially in sports that demand high strength-to-mass/power-to-weight ratios.

Lean Muscle Mass and Power.

Lean muscle mass is a key contributor to an athlete's power and strength. Achieving an optimal balance between muscle mass and body fat is paramount for various sports as is maximising lean mass in the context of the trade off with overall weight.

Many athletes chase a low weight at all costs, sacrificing the benefits of strength training and maintaining appropriate amounts of lean mass. This isn’t suprising if they have noticed an increase in performance has been associated with weight loss and often this is reinforced by parents or coaches in young athletes with old school culture, poor education and a toxic attitude and lack of knowledge about performance.

However, this can cause a belief that ‘more is better’ so athletes push their body composition to levels that can be problematic not just to performance but also to health with low body fat levels and low lean mass or lean mass losses.

Benefits: Greater lean muscle mass enhances strength, power, and explosive movements crucial for activities like sprinting, jumping, and weightlifting. However, excessive muscle mass without consideration for functionality can impact endurance.

Sex Differences in Body Composition.

Men and women often exhibit differences in body composition, influencing their athletic performance. Understanding these distinctions is vital for tailoring training and nutrition plans as well as athlete monitoring to ensure in the pursuit of low body fat, if needed to improve sport performance, is undertaken safely.

Men can reach very low levels of body fat and assuming they have used a well-stuctured approach can do this safely. It is not uncommon for males to reach single figure body fat percentages and be healthy and performing well.

The biggest issue for men is that to reach and maintain low body fat levels it can come with costs of increased hunger and desire to eat as the body ‘recognises’ the potential for low levels to get too low. That is not to say that it can’t have negative implications for men, but the consequences tend to be less severe than for women.

For women the pursuit of low body fat can come with an increased cost of severe hormonal disruption, negative effects on menstrual cycles and other health implications. A visibly lean female athlete will typically be between 10-15% bodyfat.

For ‘safety’, levels below 15% should be closely monitored for the potential impacts on health and lower than 10% is where we start to chip into essential fat that comes with incredibly high risk for no reward for athletes.

Regardless of sex, the focus should be on performance improvement as the overriding goal. The dangers of chasing low body fat can come with not just performance reductions and physiological damage, but also the psychological trauma that can come from an overly attentive focus on weight/look that is driven from both inside the culture of some sports but also from societal pressure.

Considerations: Men generally have a higher percentage of muscle mass, while women tend to store more essential body fat. Recognizing and respecting these differences ensures that performance expectations align with individual physiological characteristics.

Body Composition and Performance Optimization Strategies.

Performance-Oriented Weight Management.

Athletes often engage in aggresive weight management strategies to optimize body composition for their specific sport. However, these strategies must prioritize performance over aesthetic goals, and this may even include increases in body fat either to meet the demands of the sport directly (Strongman, Powerlifting etc.) or to find optimal performance body fat levels.

Considerations: Rapid weight loss methods can lead to muscle loss, dehydration, and compromised performance. Performance testing, including power assessments and endurance evaluations, should guide weight management strategies that enhance rather than hinder athletic capabilities.

Nutrition for Body Composition.

Nutrition plays a pivotal role in achieving and maintaining optimal body composition. Balancing macronutrients and micronutrients supports health as a foundation of muscle development, fat metabolism, and overall performance.

Guidelines: Individualized nutrition plans, informed by performance testing and metabolic assessments, ensure that athletes receive the nutrients essential for their unique energy demands. A well-fueled body is better equipped for training and competition.

The Dangers of Extreme Leanness: Balancing Health and Performance.

Health Implications of Low Body Fat.

While low body fat is often associated with enhanced performance, extreme leanness can have detrimental health effects. Athletes must be aware of the potential risks associated with very low body fat levels.

Risks: Hormonal imbalances, reproductive issues, weakened immune function, and increased susceptibility to bone injuries are among the health risks associated with extremely low body fat. Regular health assessments, including blood work, are crucial for monitoring these factors.

RED-S: Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport.

RED-S is a condition where there's an inadequate energy intake relative to the energy expended during exercise. This deficiency can lead to various health issues, affecting both male and female athletes.

Indicators: Amenorrhea (absence of menstruation) in women, impaired bone health, decreased immune function, and hormonal imbalances are red flags for RED-S. Athletes experiencing any of these symptoms should seek professional guidance.

Causes and Risks of Eating Disorders in Athletes.

Pressure to Conform to Body Ideals.

Athletes, like anyone else, can feel the pressure to conform to societal body ideals. In sports where body composition is highly emphasized, this pressure can escalate, leading to unhealthy behaviors.

Risks: Striving for an unrealistic body image can contribute to disordered eating patterns, including restrictive diets, excessive exercise, and, in severe cases, full-blown eating disorders.

Overemphasis on Weight Class Sports.

Sports with weight class categories can inadvertently promote extreme weight-cutting practices. Athletes may resort to rapid weight loss methods to fit into a specific weight class, putting their health at risk.

Risks: Unhealthy weight-cutting practices can lead to dehydration, nutrient deficiencies, and negatively impact performance. It's crucial to approach weight class sports with a focus on healthy weight management and under the supervision of genuine experts.

Dietary Approaches: Avoiding Overly Restrictive Practices.

Tailoring Nutrition to Individual Needs.

Dietary approaches should prioritize individual needs and performance goals. What works for one athlete may not be suitable for another, emphasizing the importance of personalized nutrition plans.

Benefits: Tailored nutrition plans consider an athlete's energy expenditure, training intensity, and specific nutrient requirements. Performance testing and ongoing assessments guide adjustments to ensure optimal fueling without compromising health.

Promoting a Healthy Relationship with Food.

Educating athletes about the importance of a healthy relationship with food is integral. Viewing food as fuel rather than a source of guilt or anxiety contributes to a positive mindset.

Benefits: A positive food mindset fosters a healthy relationship with nutrition, reducing the risk of disordered eating patterns. Coaches and nutrition professionals play a vital role in promoting balanced attitudes toward food.

Recognizing Sport-Specific Body Composition Norms.

Sport-Specific Guidelines.

Different sports have varying body composition norms, influenced by the demands of the activity. Athletes should aim for a body composition that aligns with the requirements of their specific sport and in line with their performance.

Examples: Endurance athletes may benefit from a lower body fat percentage for improved power-to-weight ratio, while certain strength-based sports may allow for a slightly higher body fat percentage. Tailoring body composition goals to the demands of the sport optimizes performance.

Achieving and Maintaining Optimal Body Composition.

Periodized Training and Nutrition.

Periodization isn't limited to training; it extends to nutrition and body composition goals. Athletes should integrate periodized approaches to training and nutrition that align with their seasonal and competition schedules.

Benefits: Periodized plans ensure that body composition goals are strategically addressed throughout the training cycle, preventing extreme fluctuations that could impact performance negatively.

Monitoring and Adjusting.

Regular monitoring of body composition, potentially through methods like DEXA scans, ultrasound or calliper testing, provides insights into the effectiveness of training and nutrition strategies and how they interact with each other. Measuring performance vs. body composition to find the atheltes individual performance sweet spot.

Adjustments: Athletes and their coaches can make informed adjustments to training volumes, intensity, and nutritional interventions based on monitored changes in body composition. This dynamic approach ensures ongoing optimization.

Conclusion

Striking the balance between athlete body composition and performance is a nuanced journey that requires careful consideration of individual needs, sport-specific requirements, and the overarching goal of optimizing health and capabilities. By understanding the role of body fat, lean muscle mass, and gender differences, athletes can tailor their approach to achieve the right balance.

Performance-oriented weight management, nutrition strategies, and periodic monitoring ensure that body composition goals align with the demands of training cycles and competition seasons. Importantly, athletes must recognize the dangers of extreme leanness, RED-S, and the potential risks of developing eating disorders, prioritizing health alongside performance.

In the quest for optimal body composition, athletes are not merely sculpting their physique; they are refining the instrument through which they achieve athletic excellence. The delicate dance between body composition and performance is an ongoing, dynamic process that, when approached with mindfulness and balance, leads to sustained performance success.

About the Author:

Dr Paul Rimmer (BSc, MSC, PhD SENr) r Paul holds a degree in Sports Science, post-graduate degrees in Sport Rehabilitation & Sport Nutrition and a PhD in Biomechanics.
He is a SENr Nutritionist and has over a decades experience working with athletes. He has written thousands of articles, blogs on all aspects of health and fitness. He is a 'hybrid' athlete, competing in both ultra-endurance events and powerlifting, recently completing a 100km trail ultra-marathon.

Instagram @theperformancestrategist

Blog ‘Hybrid Athlete’